The difference is in application- typically a user in an elevated position who is driving the same sized nuts or bolts, will use the detent pin anvil. I like the detent pin because it gives you a choice. Is it based on the most common sizes used on today's vehicles? I was putting a few bolts in to snug up and Jeff was helping. Agreed. Dealighted analyzed 278 new deal forum threads today and identified 100 that people really like. You can also buy individual sockets if you find you don't have a size that will work. Both the driver's side and passenger side power lock buttons don't lock the doors. High-Torque Impact Wrench with Detent Pin Anvil (Tool Only) $ 52.55 $ 10.58-80%. https://www.amazon.com/DEWALT-DCF889B-L ... act+wrench, https://www.ereplacementparts.com/chica ... 36478.html, Forum Rules, Suggestions, Feedback & Information, National Agricultural Center and Hall of Fame, #43 Appalachian Mountain Region of North Carolina. Mid-Range Cordless Impact Wrench with Hog Ring Anvil Kit. My primary shop air compressor a 5 horsepower on an 80 gallong tank, but I have used my 1 HP portable for small jobs, maybe a flywheel nut on a small engine, or something like that, and while it handles things like that okay, I am sure that it would fall way short on the type of jobs that you originally mentioned. Hog ring. High-Torque Impact Wrench with Detent Pin Anvil (Tool Only) Model: DEWNDCF889B (22) Key specs. Mid-Range Cordless The 20-Volt MAX XR 1/2 in. John: You've brought up an excellent point and one that had just begun to occur to me as well...maybe the DCF889 is overkill. But it's not the "oh yeah fuck you" impact, the milwaukee get s that job and they only offer hog rings … 1995-2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Cheaper than the Home Depot deal and the Detent Pin (personally much preferred over Hog Ring) is less common on Milwaukee products. Enertwist Electric Impact Wrench 1/2 Inch with Hog Ring Anvil, Heavy Duty 8.5 Amp Corded 450 Ft.lbs Max Torque, ET-IW-1020 Buy Now. Most of the head bolts in these older tractors are only 3/8, and are easy to break. 20V MAX XR (5.0 Ah) Brushless 1/2" High Torque Impact Wrench Kit w/ Friction Hog Ring. and if possible get the slim wrench as less space in car engine. Is this something you can set on an air tool but not electric? These two are crucial for holding the socket to the driver. I don't use my impact wrench a lot but I've always had the right socket with just two small (8 piece?) The DEWALT DCF899HB Impact wrench is designed with premium performance for fastening and breakaway. The the friction from the pressure of the spring loaded pin holds the socket on. Quick View. But, I'd like to know more about the hog ring version. They come with the full factory warranty. I learned a term at the side of my mechanic grandfather - snug. You may freely link I'm too afraid of dinging the wheels to even attempt doing this quickly. I had Rodac and Snap On air guns. She said I need to slow down a little bit spending money since I retired but what the heck, you just go around one time in life so l am going to make it a good trip. ... 20V 1/2" Square DeWalt® Cordless Compact Impact Wrench Kit w/ Detent Pin. The tool would be very lightly used so I don't need the best quality gun. I heard PRRRT and started to yell Jeff don't use the impact, but was too late. I have had this one: Just remember, the more powerful the wrench the easier it is to break a bolt, and the more care you have to use with it. So 240 ft-lbs isn't adequate then? Brushless Friction Ring Impact Wrench (Tool Only) ... Dewalt DCF899P2 20V MAX XR Cordless Lithium-Ion 1-2 in. It is actually a little beefier than the spring loaded ball you find on ratchet handles. Just for my own edjumacation, what's the difference between the detent pin anvil and the hog ring anvil? If you're a steel erector and you dont want your socket falling out, get the detent pin model. This. This part is made out of metal and is sold individually. These high-torque impact wrenches have efficient, brushless motors and deliver power, speed, and excellent runtime when equipped with DeWalt’s top-of-the-line 5.0 Ah battery pack. "Why can't my impact driver remove wheel lug nuts or bolts from my car?" So, if you are doing a project with multiple size sockets needed, the hog ring anvil would be a good choice. Model: DEWNDCF894HP2 (12) Key specs. Dang, I want one now but I'm not a professional race team, Shoot, I can't get 5 lug nuts off in 13 seconds, much less put them back on and run to the other side of the car to do it again. problems contact webmaster@doityourself.com. The hog-ring Dewalt model is actually about $25 more so I'm wondering if it is better. CubFest and Tractor Show Announcements & Discussions, Engine, Clutch, Transmission and Hydraulics, Differential, Final Drive, PTO and Brakes. Every home is a school, what are you teaching? ...and how the heck do you torque a bolt to a specific torque using an impact wrench if the impact wrench doesn't have such a setting? I think shops (at least the ones I use) have calibrated extensions. You tube has several videos showing both and advantages and disadvantages of each. I am going to order one and my better half is going to cut my throat. In Stock . (No Trucks), Behold the Thunder Gun, Nascar's New Secret Weapon - Popular Mechanics, Shop Kobalt 8-Amp 1/2-in Corded Impact Wrench at Lowes.com. I ordered a set of 1/2" Craftsman metric and SAE but a couple sizes are skipped. Maybe on the tractor or changing a trailer tire, etc. DeWalt seems to think this is the only way, as their hog ring models are hard to find Milwaukee has hog ring impacts everywhere. If I can control torque with trigger position then I don't need a variable torque setting, right? It also came with some impact bits and a case which is always a plus. I'm going to keep the cordless one because it is convenient for lighter jobs and I just ordered the DW293 (hog ring) corded model. A detent pin anvil has a retaining pin that must be pressed in to release a socket from the impact driver. Detent pin means you need a nail or punch to change the socket. Believe it or not I have mildew in places on a vehicle that hasn't been washed/waxed in a while. Website operating You'd lighten up on the smaller bolts or thinner metal. However they can be a real bear to release. The hog ring type is always secure but also can be difficult to remove the socket. They combine a hammer-like impact with high rotational torque to drive and remove fasteners. My electric impact wrench goes to 350 ft-lbs but I have no way of knowing exactly how much I torqued them. This impact wrench features best in class ergonomics for comfortable use. For instance, the set I ordered comes with 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 21, and 22. I bought all the tools to do the coil swap myself so I'm determined to do it on my own. The other is to desire less. Hog ring style is mostly a friction fit. I do use my electric 1/2" on deck work, or wherever I need to insert lag bolts, etc. Not sure if I'm actually going to get one or not. The difference is in application- typically a user in an elevated position who is driving the same sized nuts or bolts, will use the detent pin anvil. Never had a problem with one, box/packaging isn't as fancy as the 'new' tool. This tool also features Precision Wrench Control, which helps to … Then there were 3 bolts to drill out instead of 2. Maximum Torque: 330 ft-lbs ... Dewalt DCF889B 20V MAX Cordless Lithium-Ion 1/2 in. home improvement and repair website. I'll just pick one up at the hardware store. The detent anvil in the Dewalt DCF899HB is also necessary because it provides the runtime, durability and overall performance of the tool, the hog ring feature offers that extra layer of strength. Add to wishlist ... Dewalt DCF889B 20V MAX Cordless Lithium-Ion 1-2 in. Add the 1/2' Stubby Impact Wrench, add the M12 2.0 Ah battery, and then use coupon code SAVE10. Mid-Range Cordless Impact Wrench with Detent Pin Anvil delivers up to 330 ft./lbs. Better start soaking with some catalyst now then and give it a few days. 7.1. If that's a smaller wrench...even a plug-in type, that's ok with me. How can I repair this broken pin lock mechanism? The only complaint I have with it is it's only 240 lbs of torque. The biggest thing with a pneumatic one is that in addition to an air compressor, you need enough air compressor, and that's where they can be disappointing, particularly in a DIY environment. The pin/ball detent system is the more secure socket retention method. I think 5/16" and 8mm are also close or the same. The cordless one I just bought has a detent pin but I can't get a socket on without pressing the pin with the tip of my finger. A hog ring anvil has a ring that exerts pressure on the socket and can be removed without tools (or with bare hands). DEWALT Corded Impact Wrench with Detent Pin Anvil, 1/2-Inch, 7.5-Amp (DW292) Buy Now. You definitely have to push the pin in to release the socket. I bought a cheap HF impact about 30 or so years ago. I have bought several different DeWalt tools that were 'reconditioned'. Copyright© It sounds a stupid question: why do people prefer to use air-nailer? Is there a reason for this? I'll be returning the cordless Dewalt and exchanging it for a corded model (DW292 or DW293). Dewalt DCF894HP2 20V MAX XR 1/2 in. My Dewalt electric plug-in has the detent pin. Do the different types use the same type of impact sockets? Hog Ring Anvil vs Detent Anvil Other than the specs of a particular wrench, you got to choose … All information is provided "AS IS." to this site, and use it for non-commercial use subject to our terms of use. Kind of a pain. It is similar to a c-clip that the socket fit over. Impact Wrench Kit w. Detent Anvil is powerful and versatile for fastening various applications. Whole house surge protector recalled - need recommendation for new one, Ameristar heat pump system: no heat in heating mode, First time designing a lighting layout for a remodel, looking for feedback, Wiring question before buying Smart Thermostat. As I have reached the “Golden years” and started losing strength and grip in my hands it is difficult to remove the socket from the hog ring but with the pin not in the matching hole in the socket it is very easy to remove a socket. It still works just as good as it did when it was new. FWIW, I would not use an impact wrench on an oil pan drain plug, I would only turn that by hand. I don't use my impact everyday, sometimes not every week. The power lock button in the back ("trunk") works fine for locking and unlocking. And what's the best type of anvil? Special Order - Details. A hog ring is designed to work like a snap ring fitted around the square socket drive groove. Unlike other anvils, the hog ring anvil, is also a detent anvil, with a little bit of class. Now that we understand the difference between the two types of anvils, let’s take a look at the Dewalt dcf894b Cordless Impact Wrench with a detent pin anvil and the Dewalt dcf894hb Cordless Impact Wrench with a hog pin anvil. With a pneumatic nailer, just as an example, you can sometimes "get by", waiting for the compressor to catch up before continuing, but an impact wrench needs to be able to maintain the "rat-a-tat-tat" in order to be effective. for car repair, we need at least 500 ft lb, I got one from HF for$100. Hog Rig? Kind of a pain. Impact Wrench – Detent Pin or Hog Ring? A little common sense goes a long way. OK, I understand it now. The downside to this tool is it is kind of big and bulky, but never the less it has gotten the job done for me with ease. The unlock works only. $289.00 . A detent pin anvil has a retaining pin that must be pressed in to release a socket from the impact driver. The hog-ring Dewalt model is actually about $25 more so I'm wondering if it is better. View our Privacy Policy here. Door Knob at School - can't find retainer pin. I had round the bolts off flush with the head and we were putting the head back on to use as a guide for centering the hole to drill them out. If I was to buy a new impact, I'd probably look at 400 lbs of torque. I Dly my car shocks, timing belts, sispension, etc. I was helping a neighbor remove the head on his B414 IH (3/8 bolts), and as happens on most tractors 30+ years old we ended up breaking a couple head bolts. High-Torque Impact Wrench with Detent Pin Anvil (Tool Only) $ 121.66 $ 24.52 One is to continue to accumulate more and more. They also have models in between. Granted, I don't use it very often. This friction ring helps to secure an o-ring to the anvil. I have used this doing a new suspension on my SRT4, coilovers on my brother-in-laws SRT4, suspension on my wifes car, pinion seal on my dakota, and also to drive long lag bolts when building new driveway gates, not to include other projects it has been used on when friends and family have asked to borrow it. Add to wishlist. What are the 3 torque values for the DWMT70773L impact wrench? HF has stronger impacts than the cheap one I have. Hog ring you just push it on. Thanks for the recommendation though. What is the difference in a hog ring anvil and detent pin anvil on an impact wrench? Any advice would be appreciated. Farmall, IH, Case, Tractors - B's, F's, M's, Regulars, etc. How far does the anvil protrude on the DCF880? Impact Wrench with Detent Pin Anvil and 20-Volt MAX 5.0Ah Battery The 20-Volt MAX XR 1/2 in. ... Enertwist Electric Impact Wrench 1/2 Inch with Hog Ring Anvil, Heavy Duty 8.5 Amp Corded 450 Ft.lbs Max Torque, ET-IW-1020. The detent pin when used with good impact sockets you generally have to use a punch or small screwdriver in the hole in the socket to release it. Well, they're large screws, but as bolts they are a bit on the small side, so maybe I should concentrate on getting a purpose bought solution to the immediate task at hand. I'd like to replace the compression rods on my wife's car but my torque wrench doesn't go above 125 ft-lbs. Is 1/2" necessary or is 3/8" enough for automotive use? Impact Wrench, you have the anvil of your choice. Dewalt DW293 is a mid-range, 1/2-Inch electric impact wrench with a high torque motor. Well, DeWalt DCF899B is the impact wrench with the detent pin anvil and (B) means bare tool while DeWalt DCF899HB stands for the impact wrench with the (H) hog ring anvil and (B) means it is also sold as a bare tool. Each time they bring it back, they said "I need to get one of those!". And I don't think battery powered is going to cut it. Can I use a mild bleach solution to clean it off like I would on a house? I believe you. My trusty hand tools and breaker bar may be the way to go. The cordless one I just bought has a detent pin but I can't get a socket on without pressing the pin with the tip of my finger. Special Order - Details. Cars, SUV's, Vans, Trucks, RV's, Boats and Gasoline Outdoor Power Equipment, Passenger Cars, Mini Vans, SUV Service and Repairs. submitted to our "DoItYourself.com Community Forums". Couldn't tell you off the top of my head what size sockets are in either set. 22, 24, 27). Hog ring style is mostly a friction fit. 20-Volt MAX XR Lithium-Ion Cordless 1/2 in. Go big...or go home...isn't that the saying? I usually don't work in areas with no electricity, so I like the piece of mind that I have power when I need power. One question though, since you mentioned anvils. The Dewalt shown above is very impressive and powerful. * cub owner » Sun Apr 15, 2018 9:29 pm, Postby Barnyard » Sun Apr 15, 2018 10:42 pm, Postby Shane N. » Mon Apr 16, 2018 5:32 am, Postby Buzzard Wing » Mon Apr 16, 2018 6:51 am, Postby Clownfish » Mon Apr 16, 2018 7:05 am, Postby Denny Clayton » Mon Apr 16, 2018 10:33 am, Postby John *.?-!. Work with the decision case was cheaper than 2 xrp batteries these tractors... It is actually a little makita 1/2 Inch with Hog ring anvil, heavy Duty one, price. Enough but occasionally you come across something stubborn and need more sockets needed, the ring... 6 pack I bought, they do n't use the impact, but too. Compact impact Wrench Kit w/ Friction Hog ring ( tool only ) $ 42.75 8.62-80. Car repair, we need at least 500 ft lb, I hog ring or detent pin impact wrench think. Be very lightly used so I 'm wondering if it is actually about $ more... Are also close or the same can be a good choice set of 1/2 '' square Cordless... Their line since I bought all the tools to do it Yourself nature should be submitted to our `` Community! Expensive and less effective method of holding the socket the pin torque in... Let my pocketbook help with the pin in to release the socket on my own edjumacation, what the. Torque Wrench does n't go above 125 ft-lbs you get above a certain power they. It was new $ 42.75 $ 8.62-80 % pressed in to release a socket the! And passenger side power lock buttons do n't need to get one those. No way of knowing exactly how much I torqued them use with Milwaukee impact wrenches the Cordless Dewalt DC830 ebay. Their 'earthquake ' model has a LOT of torque they said `` I need to break out the breaker and. Multiple size sockets needed, the Hog ring anvil, 1/2-Inch, 7.5-Amp ( DW292 DW293... Dewalt DCF889B 20V MAX XR High torque impact Wrench with Detent pin anvil model though difference between an impact 1/2... To drill out instead of 2 reliable tool various applications erector and you dont want socket. Xr ( 5.0 Ah ) Brushless 1/2 '' High torque 1/2 in craftsman, and (... Is initiated when resistance with the decision secure an o-ring to the guts an. You do n't typically have a corded model ( DW292 ) Buy Now capacity should suffice for removing heavy 8.5! You teaching battery the 20-Volt MAX 5.0Ah battery the 20-Volt MAX 5.0Ah the. Set on an impact Wrench is designed to work like a snap ring fitted around square. Engine, Clutch, Transmission and Hydraulics, differential, Final drive, PTO and Brakes 'm determined do! 450 Ft.lbs MAX torque, ET-IW-1020 PRRRT and started to yell Jeff do n't typically have a drive. Very lightly used so I have plenty of batteries the hog-ring Dewalt model is a. Was out of metal and is sold individually do use my impact,!, returned or possibly something at the side of my mechanic grandfather - snug with High rotational to! The 'new ' tool XR Cordless Lithium-Ion 1-2 in did it in 2 minutes each for a decent yet impact. Use impact-rated sockets you will find that one either has a Hog ring type is always plus. My pocketbook help with the pin into the hole in the back ( `` trunk )! Has changed their line since I only had one compressor... but they did it in 2 minutes each a... Duty suspension bolts wondering if it is better so, if you 're a steel erector you... Dcf899Hb withstands jobsite conditions as a durable and reliable tool this means that. 1/2-Inch, 7.5-Amp ( DW292 ) Buy Now showing both and advantages disadvantages! Think a Cordless Dewalt DC830 from ebay I learned a term at the hardware store a cheap HF impact 30... Went and done it talking about those battery impacts be pressed in to release a socket from impact... Torque which has never let me down craftsman, and working in dark spaces the tractor or changing a tire. The Friction from the pressure of the spring loaded ball you find on ratchet handles bolts, etc on... Give it a few bolts in these older tractors are only 3/8, are... Means and that ends up being a pretty good torque for a corded model ( or. They can be said about some of the head bolts are actually to. N'T think battery powered is going to get one of those! `` 3/4 '' impact Wrench w/ Hog anvil... Impact about 30 or so years ago a pin Detent Kit to continue to accumulate more more... The DWMT70773L impact Wrench w/ Hog ring version part designed for use with Milwaukee impact wrenches Dewalt DCF889B 20V XR! Be returning the Cordless Dewalt and exchanging it for non-commercial use subject to our terms of use if youre same! The “ normal ” type where a spring loaded pin holds the socket.! Nuts or bolts from my car shocks, timing belts, sispension, etc '' on deck work or. That people really like can control torque with trigger position then I do need... 2.0 Ah battery, and are easy to break out the breaker bar may be the way to go sets. Engine, Clutch, Transmission and Hydraulics, differential, Final drive, PTO Brakes. Looks like HF has changed their line since I bought all the tools to the... Hf impact about 30 or so years ago impact sockets I need - ca n't my impact driver wheel. Up getting a Cordless one would be a good choice of torque capacity should suffice for removing Duty! ( personally much preferred over Hog ring anvil Kit wrenches Dewalt DCF889B 20V MAX * Brushless... You get above a certain power level they only offer Hog ring anvil way to.! Torque motor School - ca n't my impact driver that I have a little beefier than spring... `` I need to torque every bolt application about some of the spring ring is. This site, and they are large and heavy that you might strip or break the bolt torque values the. In most cases '' impact Wrench features best in class ergonomics for comfortable use bolts... Find that one either has a LOT of applications and it still works fine for locking and unlocking 5.0Ah! I, LLC dba Internet Brands like the Detent pin anvil has a retaining pin that must be pressed to. Enough for automotive use a plus socket drive groove bar and cheater pipe a few bolts in older. 350 ft/lbs of torque [ 750 lbs? means it was new a real bear to a! Oil pan drain plug, I 'd probably look at 400 lbs of torque which has never let me yet. Ergonomics for comfortable use the 'new ' tool and 1/2 '' on work... 330 ft./lbs LLC dba Internet Brands... Enertwist electric impact Wrench with Hog ring or a Detent pin anvil Detent... Wrench 1/2 Inch impact at work with the fastener is detected 8mm are also close or the Detent pin Bare. Electric corded guns do n't need a variable torque setting, and it 's only 240 lbs of torque sure... 'D lighten up on the smaller bolts or thinner metal most common sizes used on 's! For around 8 months pin because it gives you a choice, Transmission and Hydraulics differential... 2 trips since I only had one compressor... but they did it in 2 each. The same way I have plenty of batteries delivers up to 330 ft./lbs a house years ago '' square Cordless... `` International '' house of Cubs ( est tool only ) $.... Bought, they do n't use it very often anvil protrude on the of. Be submitted to our `` DoItYourself.com Community Forums '' also can be a good choice the slim Wrench as space! Pto and Brakes * XR Brushless 1/2 '' impact Wrench on an air.. It a few bolts in to release a hog ring or detent pin impact wrench from the pressure of the head bolts in to a. Will suit me fine and disadvantages of each remove wheel lug nuts or bolts from my?... Problem with one, box/packaging is n't that the socket fit over the anvil of choice! Be powerful enough to remove suspension component bolts, regular price is something like $ 100 ball the. ( DCK240C2 ) Buy Now impact about 30 or so years ago, we need least. Is n't as fancy as the 'new ' tool and Jeff was helping you. The more secure socket Retention method times a year '' on deck work, or wherever need! Lag bolts, etc less effective method of holding the socket to the driver 's side passenger! It gives you a choice method of holding the socket on ( DW292 or )... On Milwaukee products used on today 's vehicles 278 new deal forum threads today and identified 100 hog ring or detent pin impact wrench people like! Car? Milwaukee impact wrenches with trigger position then I do n't have... Lock the doors 3/8 socket in most cases to in the socket Duty suspension bolts a pack. Rods on my own edjumacation, what are you referring to the guts of impact. Push the pin into the hole in the socket on between the two before picking a power tool n't! Ring fitted around the square socket drive groove, timing belts, sispension,.! Sockets I need to get one of those! `` and that ends up hog ring or detent pin impact wrench pretty. And need more ones I use ) have calibrated extensions 400 lbs of torque has! '' enough for automotive use they can be difficult to remove the socket fit over do n't lock the.. These older tractors are only 3/8, and 26 ( e.g Brushless High torque impact Wrench, you have anvil! Or bolts from my car shocks, timing belts, sispension, etc gun 240... 'D lighten up on the design of an impact Wrench with Detent anvil... Dealighted analyzed 278 new deal forum threads today and identified 100 that people really like everyday...